- Location: Kenosha, WI 1962-present; Carthage, IL 1870-1962
- Nickname: Firebirds (Red Men until 2021)
- Conference: College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin 1962-present
- Division: III
- Ballpark: Carthage Baseball Field
- J.A. Baird, 1910-1915
- Forest Loudin, 1916-1917; 1920-1921
- L. Paul Lavinn, 1947
- Henry Keil, 1948
- Bill Strickland, 1949-1950
- Loel Frederickson, 1951-1952
- Donald Robinson, 1953-1954
- Art Keller, 1955-1956
- Dwight Marston, 1957-1960
- Larry Hamilton, 1961
- Augie Schmidt III, 1962-1980
- Bill Egbert, 1981-1983
- Mark Stalker, 1984-1986
- Mark Resop, 1987
- Augie Schmidt IV, 1988-present
- Carthage College did not field teams in 1918 and 1919, due to World War I.
- Carthage College did not field teams from 1922 to 1946.
- Carthage College was not affiliated with a conference from 1953 to 1961.