Robert C. Winchester
"Dorgan, Martin Powell, Winchester, Gillespie and Connor were a quintette of batters without superiors in those days." - a correspondent to Sporting Life, recalling the great Holyoke team in the late 1870's, from the June 19, 1889 issue
Robert Winchester played for the Holyoke Club in 1879. He played in 45 games, and collected 61 hits in 204 at bats, for a .299 batting average.