Career Leaders & Records for Wins Above Replacement
Create your own custom leaderboards
Become a Stathead today and run queries with our Season and Career Finders to see the best seasons in MLB history.
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Babe Ruth+ (22) | 183.1 | 10626 | 1221.1 | L |
| 2. | Walter Johnson+ (21) | 164.9 | 2534 | 5914.1 | R |
| 3. | Cy Young+ (22) | 163.6 | 3104 | 7356.0 | R |
| 4. | Barry Bonds (22) | 162.8 | 12606 | L | |
| 5. | Willie Mays+ (23) | 156.1 | 12545 | R | |
| 6. | Ty Cobb+ (24) | 151.5 | 13103 | 5.0 | L |
| 7. | Henry Aaron+ (23) | 143.0 | 13941 | R | |
| 8. | Roger Clemens (24) | 139.2 | 213 | 4916.2 | R |
| 9. | Tris Speaker+ (22) | 134.7 | 12020 | 1.0 | L |
| 10. | Honus Wagner+ (21) | 130.8 | 11766 | 8.1 | R |
| 11. | Stan Musial+ (22) | 128.6 | 12721 | 0.0 | L |
| 12. | Rogers Hornsby+ (23) | 127.3 | 9481 | R | |
| 13. | Eddie Collins+ (25) | 124.4 | 12087 | L | |
| 14. | Ted Williams+ (19) | 122.0 | 9792 | 2.0 | L |
| 15. | Pete Alexander+ (20) | 119.3 | 1981 | 5190.0 | R |
| 16. | Alex Rodriguez (22) | 117.6 | 12207 | R | |
| 17. | Kid Nichols+ (15) | 116.3 | 2264 | 5067.1 | B |
| 18. | Lou Gehrig+ (17) | 113.6 | 9665 | L | |
| 19. | Rickey Henderson+ (25) | 111.1 | 13346 | R | |
| 20. | Mel Ott+ (22) | 110.8 | 11347 | L | |
| 21. | Mickey Mantle+ (18) | 110.2 | 9910 | B | |
| 22. | Tom Seaver+ (20) | 109.9 | 1552 | 4783.0 | R |
| 23. | Frank Robinson+ (21) | 107.2 | 11744 | R | |
| 24. | Nap Lajoie+ (21) | 106.9 | 10471 | R | |
| 25. | Lefty Grove+ (17) | 106.8 | 1580 | 3940.2 | L |
| Mike Schmidt+ (18) | 106.8 | 10062 | R | ||
| 27. | Greg Maddux+ (23) | 106.6 | 1812 | 5008.1 | R |
| Christy Mathewson+ (17) | 106.6 | 1900 | 4788.2 | R | |
| 29. | Randy Johnson+ (22) | 101.1 | 691 | 4135.1 | R |
| 30. | Joe Morgan+ (22) | 100.4 | 11329 | L | |
| 31. | Warren Spahn+ (21) | 100.1 | 2056 | 5243.2 | L |
| 32. | Albert Pujols (22, 42) | 99.7 | 12771 | 1.0 | R |
| 33. | Carl Yastrzemski+ (23) | 96.5 | 13992 | L | |
| 34. | Eddie Mathews+ (17) | 96.1 | 10101 | L | |
| 35. | Phil Niekro+ (24) | 95.9 | 1707 | 5404.0 | R |
| Cal Ripken Jr.+ (21) | 95.9 | 12883 | R | ||
| 37. | Roberto Clemente+ (18) | 94.8 | 10212 | R | |
| 38. | Bert Blyleven+ (22) | 94.5 | 514 | 4970.0 | R |
| 39. | Cap Anson+ (27) | 94.3 | 11331 | 4.0 | R |
| 40. | Adrian Beltre (21) | 93.5 | 12130 | R | |
| 41. | Jimmie Foxx+ (20) | 93.1 | 9677 | 23.2 | R |
| 42. | Al Kaline+ (22) | 92.9 | 11597 | R | |
| 43. | Wade Boggs+ (18) | 91.4 | 10740 | 2.1 | L |
| 44. | Eddie Plank+ (17) | 90.8 | 1783 | 4495.2 | L |
| 45. | Steve Carlton+ (24) | 90.2 | 1881 | 5217.2 | L |
| 46. | Gaylord Perry+ (22) | 90.0 | 1220 | 5350.0 | R |
| 47. | Bob Gibson+ (17) | 89.2 | 1489 | 3884.1 | R |
| 48. | George Brett+ (21) | 88.6 | 11625 | L | |
| 49. | Tim Keefe+ (14) | 86.9 | 2262 | 5049.2 | R |
| 50. | Robin Roberts+ (19) | 86.1 | 1784 | 4688.2 | B |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 51. | Chipper Jones+ (19) | 85.3 | 10614 | B | |
| 52. | Charlie Gehringer+ (19) | 84.8 | 10245 | L | |
| 53. | George Davis+ (20) | 84.5 | 10188 | 4.0 | B |
| 54. | Roger Connor+ (18) | 84.3 | 8847 | B | |
| 55. | Fergie Jenkins+ (19) | 84.1 | 1010 | 4500.2 | R |
| 56. | Pedro Martinez+ (18) | 83.9 | 518 | 2827.1 | R |
| 57. | Ken Griffey Jr.+ (22) | 83.8 | 11304 | L | |
| 58. | John Clarkson+ (12) | 83.2 | 2060 | 4536.1 | R |
| 59. | Mike Mussina+ (18) | 82.8 | 54 | 3562.2 | L |
| 60. | Nolan Ryan+ (27) | 81.3 | 957 | 5386.0 | R |
| 61. | Rod Carew+ (19) | 81.2 | 10550 | L | |
| 62. | Tom Glavine+ (22) | 80.7 | 1645 | 4413.1 | L |
| 63. | Jeff Bagwell+ (15) | 79.9 | 9431 | R | |
| 64. | Pete Rose (24) | 79.6 | 15890 | B | |
| 65. | Curt Schilling (20) | 79.5 | 901 | 3261.0 | R |
| 66. | Joe DiMaggio+ (13) | 79.2 | 7672 | R | |
| 67. | Mike Trout (12, 30) | 79.0 | 5831 | R | |
| 68. | Dan Brouthers+ (19) | 78.7 | 7691 | 23.0 | L |
| 69. | Brooks Robinson+ (23) | 78.5 | 11782 | R | |
| 70. | Arky Vaughan+ (14) | 78.0 | 7723 | L | |
| 71. | Luke Appling+ (20) | 77.6 | 10254 | R | |
| 72. | Robin Yount+ (20) | 77.4 | 12249 | R | |
| 73. | Ozzie Smith+ (19) | 76.9 | 10778 | B | |
| 74. | Bobby Wallace+ (25) | 76.3 | 9631 | 402.0 | R |
| 75. | Jim McCormick (10) | 76.2 | 2104 | 4275.2 | R |
| 76. | Paul Molitor+ (21) | 75.6 | 12167 | R | |
| 77. | Old Hoss Radbourn+ (12) | 75.4 | 2654 | 4527.1 | R |
| 78. | Sam Crawford+ (19) | 75.3 | 10625 | L | |
| 79. | Bill Dahlen (21) | 75.2 | 10438 | R | |
| 80. | Johnny Bench+ (17) | 75.1 | 8674 | R | |
| Lou Whitaker (19) | 75.1 | 9967 | L | ||
| 82. | Paul Waner+ (20) | 74.7 | 10767 | L | |
| 83. | Zack Greinke (19, 38) | 74.3 | 600 | 3157.2 | R |
| 84. | Reggie Jackson+ (21) | 74.0 | 11418 | L | |
| 85. | Justin Verlander (17, 39) | 73.9 | 60 | 3039.2 | R |
| 86. | Frank Thomas+ (19) | 73.8 | 10075 | R | |
| 87. | Pud Galvin+ (15) | 73.4 | 2788 | 6003.1 | R |
| 88. | Clayton Kershaw (15, 34) | 73.3 | 847 | 2484.2 | L |
| 89. | Jim Thome+ (22) | 73.1 | 10313 | L | |
| 90. | Larry Walker+ (17) | 72.7 | 8030 | L | |
| 91. | Harry Heilmann+ (17) | 72.5 | 8972 | R | |
| 92. | Rafael Palmeiro (20) | 71.9 | 12046 | L | |
| 93. | Frankie Frisch+ (19) | 71.8 | 10101 | B | |
| 94. | Derek Jeter+ (20) | 71.3 | 12602 | R | |
| 95. | Bobby Grich (17) | 71.1 | 8220 | R | |
| 96. | Johnny Mize+ (15) | 70.7 | 7372 | L | |
| Alan Trammell+ (20) | 70.7 | 9376 | R | ||
| 98. | Barry Larkin+ (19) | 70.5 | 9057 | R | |
| Ted Lyons+ (21) | 70.5 | 1729 | 4161.0 | B | |
| Ron Santo+ (15) | 70.5 | 9397 | R | ||
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 101. | Gary Carter+ (19) | 70.2 | 9019 | R | |
| 102. | Carlos Beltran (20) | 70.1 | 11031 | B | |
| Scott Rolen (17) | 70.1 | 8518 | R | ||
| 104. | Ed Delahanty+ (16) | 69.6 | 8402 | R | |
| 105. | Rick Reuschel (19) | 69.5 | 1304 | 3548.1 | R |
| 106. | Tim Raines+ (23) | 69.4 | 10359 | B | |
| 107. | Manny Ramirez (19) | 69.3 | 9774 | R | |
| 108. | Tony Gwynn+ (20) | 69.2 | 10232 | L | |
| 109. | Miguel Cabrera (20, 39) | 69.0 | 11146 | R | |
| John Smoltz+ (21) | 69.0 | 1167 | 3473.0 | R | |
| 111. | Robinson Canó (17, 39) | 68.7 | 9513 | L | |
| Eddie Murray+ (21) | 68.7 | 12817 | B | ||
| Ivan Rodriguez+ (21) | 68.7 | 10270 | R | ||
| 114. | Red Ruffing+ (22) | 68.6 | 2084 | 4344.0 | R |
| 115. | Carlton Fisk+ (24) | 68.5 | 9853 | R | |
| Carl Hubbell+ (16) | 68.5 | 1397 | 3590.1 | R | |
| Jim Palmer+ (19) | 68.5 | 537 | 3948.0 | R | |
| 118. | Kenny Lofton (17) | 68.4 | 9235 | L | |
| Edgar Martinez+ (18) | 68.4 | 8674 | R | ||
| Pee Wee Reese+ (16) | 68.4 | 9472 | R | ||
| 121. | Al Simmons+ (20) | 68.2 | 9520 | R | |
| 122. | Graig Nettles (22) | 68.0 | 10228 | L | |
| Ryne Sandberg+ (16) | 68.0 | 9282 | R | ||
| Max Scherzer (15, 37) | 68.0 | 529 | 2586.1 | R | |
| 125. | Fred Clarke+ (21) | 67.9 | 9864 | L | |
| 126. | Kevin Brown (19) | 67.8 | 575 | 3256.1 | R |
| 127. | Ernie Banks+ (19) | 67.7 | 10396 | R | |
| 128. | Dwight Evans (20) | 67.2 | 10569 | R | |
| 129. | Don Drysdale+ (14) | 67.1 | 1309 | 3432.0 | R |
| 130. | Roberto Alomar+ (17) | 67.0 | 10400 | B | |
| 131. | Don Sutton+ (23) | 66.7 | 1559 | 5282.1 | R |
| 132. | Tony Mullane (13) | 66.6 | 2971 | 4531.1 | B |
| 133. | Goose Goslin+ (18) | 66.4 | 9830 | L | |
| 134. | Buddy Bell (18) | 66.3 | 10009 | R | |
| 135. | Luis Tiant (19) | 66.1 | 570 | 3486.1 | R |
| 136. | Willie Randolph (18) | 65.9 | 9462 | R | |
| Duke Snider+ (18) | 65.9 | 8237 | L | ||
| Ed Walsh+ (14) | 65.9 | 1173 | 2964.1 | R | |
| 139. | Amos Rusie+ (10) | 65.8 | 1765 | 3778.2 | R |
| 140. | Craig Biggio+ (20) | 65.5 | 12504 | R | |
| 141. | Andre Dawson+ (21) | 64.8 | 10769 | R | |
| 142. | Joe Cronin+ (20) | 64.7 | 8840 | R | |
| 143. | Willie McCovey+ (22) | 64.5 | 9692 | L | |
| Reggie Smith (17) | 64.5 | 8051 | B | ||
| Chase Utley (16) | 64.5 | 7863 | L | ||
| 146. | Richie Ashburn+ (15) | 64.2 | 9737 | L | |
| Roy Halladay+ (16) | 64.2 | 305 | 2749.1 | R | |
| Dave Winfield+ (22) | 64.2 | 12358 | R | ||
| 149. | Red Faber+ (20) | 64.0 | 1559 | 4086.2 | B |
| 150. | Clark Griffith+ (21) | 63.8 | 1590 | 3385.2 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Jackie Robinson+ (11) | 63.8 | 5941 | R | ||
| Joey Votto (16, 38) | 63.8 | 8246 | L | ||
| 153. | Billy Williams+ (18) | 63.6 | 10519 | L | |
| 154. | Bob Feller+ (18) | 63.5 | 1486 | 3827.0 | R |
| 155. | Lou Boudreau+ (15) | 63.3 | 7025 | R | |
| 156. | Billy Hamilton+ (14) | 63.2 | 7609 | L | |
| Vic Willis+ (13) | 63.2 | 1632 | 3996.0 | R | |
| 158. | Juan Marichal+ (16) | 62.9 | 1343 | 3507.0 | R |
| 159. | Home Run Baker+ (13) | 62.8 | 6677 | L | |
| Ken Boyer (15) | 62.8 | 8274 | R | ||
| 161. | Andruw Jones (17) | 62.7 | 8664 | R | |
| Hal Newhouser+ (17) | 62.7 | 1160 | 2993.0 | L | |
| 163. | David Cone (17) | 62.3 | 470 | 2898.2 | L |
| CC Sabathia (19) | 62.3 | 127 | 3577.1 | L | |
| John Ward+ (17) | 62.3 | 8114 | 2469.2 | L | |
| Mickey Welch+ (13) | 62.3 | 2286 | 4802.0 | R | |
| 167. | Shoeless Joe Jackson (13) | 62.2 | 5697 | L | |
| 168. | Dennis Eckersley+ (24) | 62.1 | 196 | 3285.2 | R |
| Mark McGwire (16) | 62.1 | 7660 | R | ||
| 170. | Todd Helton (17) | 61.8 | 9453 | L | |
| 171. | Jack Glasscock (17) | 61.6 | 7552 | 7.0 | R |
| Tommy John (26) | 61.6 | 1030 | 4710.1 | R | |
| 173. | Sal Bando (16) | 61.5 | 8289 | 3.0 | R |
| Stan Coveleski+ (14) | 61.5 | 1196 | 3082.0 | R | |
| Bullet Rogan+ (13) | 61.5 | 2376 | 1500.0 | R | |
| 176. | Jake Beckley+ (20) | 61.2 | 10518 | 4.0 | L |
| 177. | Early Wynn+ (23) | 61.0 | 1904 | 4564.0 | B |
| 178. | Tommy Bond (10) | 60.9 | 1997 | 3628.2 | R |
| 179. | Charlie Buffinton (11) | 60.7 | 2309 | 3404.0 | R |
| Willie Davis (18) | 60.7 | 9822 | L | ||
| 181. | Gary Sheffield (22) | 60.5 | 10947 | R | |
| Zack Wheat+ (19) | 60.5 | 10007 | L | ||
| 183. | Jim Edmonds (17) | 60.4 | 7980 | L | |
| 184. | Keith Hernandez (17) | 60.3 | 8553 | L | |
| Harmon Killebrew+ (22) | 60.3 | 9833 | R | ||
| Al Spalding+ (8) | 60.3 | 1988 | 2886.1 | R | |
| Dazzy Vance+ (16) | 60.3 | 1114 | 2966.2 | R | |
| 188. | Bobby Abreu (18) | 60.2 | 10081 | L | |
| Andy Pettitte (18) | 60.2 | 237 | 3316.0 | L | |
| 190. | Wes Ferrell (15) | 60.1 | 1345 | 2623.0 | R |
| 191. | Ichiro Suzuki (19) | 60.0 | 10734 | 1.0 | L |
| 192. | Jesse Burkett+ (16) | 59.7 | 9629 | 123.0 | L |
| 193. | Jim Bunning+ (17) | 59.5 | 1401 | 3760.1 | R |
| Bob Caruthers (10) | 59.5 | 2906 | 2828.2 | L | |
| Vladimir Guerrero+ (16) | 59.5 | 9059 | R | ||
| Mike Piazza+ (16) | 59.5 | 7745 | R | ||
| 197. | Yogi Berra+ (19) | 59.4 | 8364 | L | |
| Sherry Magee (16) | 59.4 | 8557 | R | ||
| 199. | Mark Buehrle (16) | 59.1 | 140 | 3283.1 | L |
| 200. | Eddie Cicotte (14) | 59.0 | 1232 | 3226.0 | B |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Cole Hamels (15) | 59.0 | 778 | 2698.0 | L | |
| Joe McGinnity+ (10) | 59.0 | 1424 | 3441.1 | R | |
| 203. | Bret Saberhagen (16) | 58.9 | 227 | 2562.2 | R |
| 204. | Darrell Evans (21) | 58.8 | 10737 | L | |
| 205. | Dick Allen (15) | 58.7 | 7315 | R | |
| Jack Quinn (23) | 58.7 | 1513 | 3920.1 | R | |
| 207. | Urban Shocker (13) | 58.6 | 1050 | 2681.2 | R |
| Sammy Sosa (18) | 58.6 | 9896 | R | ||
| 209. | Rube Waddell+ (13) | 58.4 | 1139 | 2961.1 | R |
| 210. | Mordecai Brown+ (14) | 58.3 | 1244 | 3172.1 | B |
| 211. | John Olerud (17) | 58.2 | 9063 | L | |
| 212. | Chuck Finley (17) | 57.9 | 59 | 3197.1 | L |
| Tim Hudson (17) | 57.9 | 710 | 3126.2 | R | |
| 214. | Bobby Bonds (14) | 57.8 | 8090 | R | |
| Enos Slaughter+ (19) | 57.8 | 9087 | L | ||
| 216. | Willie Stargell+ (21) | 57.5 | 9027 | L | |
| Joe Torre+ (18) | 57.5 | 8802 | R | ||
| 218. | Evan Longoria (15, 36) | 57.4 | 7711 | R | |
| 219. | Billy Herman+ (15) | 57.3 | 8641 | R | |
| 220. | Whitey Ford+ (16) | 57.1 | 1208 | 3170.1 | L |
| George Sisler+ (15) | 57.1 | 9018 | 111.0 | L | |
| Frank Tanana (21) | 57.1 | 64 | 4188.1 | L | |
| 223. | Will Clark (15) | 56.5 | 8283 | L | |
| Larry Doby+ (17) | 56.5 | 6920 | L | ||
| Bill Terry+ (14) | 56.5 | 7111 | L | ||
| 226. | Bill Dickey+ (17) | 56.4 | 7065 | L | |
| Dave Stieb (16) | 56.4 | 2 | 2895.1 | R | |
| 228. | Johnny Damon (18) | 56.3 | 10917 | L | |
| Mariano Rivera+ (19) | 56.3 | 4 | 1283.2 | R | |
| 230. | Robin Ventura (16) | 56.1 | 8271 | 1.0 | L |
| 231. | Orel Hershiser (18) | 56.0 | 949 | 3130.1 | R |
| Jim Whitney (10) | 56.0 | 2306 | 3496.1 | L | |
| 233. | Luis Aparicio+ (18) | 55.9 | 11231 | R | |
| Gabby Hartnett+ (20) | 55.9 | 7300 | R | ||
| Eppa Rixey+ (21) | 55.9 | 1667 | 4494.2 | R | |
| 236. | Joe Gordon+ (11) | 55.8 | 6537 | R | |
| 237. | George Uhle (17) | 55.7 | 1513 | 3119.2 | R |
| Jim Wynn (15) | 55.7 | 8011 | R | ||
| 239. | Bob Johnson (13) | 55.6 | 8051 | R | |
| Chet Lemon (16) | 55.6 | 7874 | R | ||
| 241. | Hank Greenberg+ (13) | 55.5 | 6098 | R | |
| Stan Hack (16) | 55.5 | 8509 | L | ||
| 243. | Jeff Kent (17) | 55.4 | 9537 | R | |
| Jack Powell (16) | 55.4 | 1764 | 4389.0 | R | |
| 245. | Max Carey+ (20) | 55.3 | 10772 | B | |
| David Ortiz+ (20) | 55.3 | 10091 | L | ||
| 247. | Joe Mauer (15) | 55.2 | 7960 | L | |
| 248. | Bobby Mathews (15) | 55.1 | 2559 | 4956.0 | R |
| 249. | Joe Sewell+ (14) | 54.7 | 8333 | L | |
| 250. | Kevin Appier (16) | 54.5 | 90 | 2595.1 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Joe Medwick+ (17) | 54.5 | 8143 | R | ||
| 252. | Jose Cruz (19) | 54.4 | 8931 | L | |
| Sam Rice+ (20) | 54.4 | 10260 | 39.1 | L | |
| 254. | Willie Keeler+ (19) | 54.2 | 9619 | L | |
| Vada Pinson (18) | 54.2 | 10405 | L | ||
| 256. | Ian Kinsler (14) | 54.1 | 8299 | 1.0 | R |
| 257. | Tony Perez+ (23) | 54.0 | 10861 | R | |
| 258. | Ron Cey (17) | 53.8 | 8344 | R | |
| Minnie Minoso+ (20) | 53.8 | 8233 | R | ||
| 260. | Wilbur Cooper (15) | 53.6 | 1317 | 3480.0 | R |
| Harry Hooper+ (17) | 53.6 | 10277 | 2.0 | L | |
| Jerry Koosman (19) | 53.6 | 1052 | 3839.1 | R | |
| 263. | Bucky Walters (19) | 53.5 | 2150 | 3104.2 | R |
| David Wells (21) | 53.5 | 200 | 3439.0 | L | |
| 265. | Jimmy Collins+ (14) | 53.3 | 7460 | R | |
| Billy Pierce (18) | 53.3 | 1255 | 3306.2 | L | |
| 267. | Joe Tinker+ (15) | 53.2 | 7166 | R | |
| 268. | Jack Clark (18) | 53.1 | 8230 | R | |
| 269. | Bert Campaneris (19) | 53.0 | 9625 | 1.0 | R |
| Paul Goldschmidt (12, 34) | 53.0 | 6486 | R | ||
| Dwight Gooden (16) | 53.0 | 849 | 2800.2 | R | |
| 272. | Cesar Cedeno (17) | 52.9 | 8133 | R | |
| 273. | Burleigh Grimes+ (19) | 52.8 | 1687 | 4180.0 | R |
| 274. | Babe Adams (19) | 52.7 | 1111 | 2995.1 | L |
| Elmer Flick+ (13) | 52.7 | 6434 | L | ||
| 276. | Fred McGriff (19) | 52.6 | 10174 | L | |
| 277. | Bid McPhee+ (18) | 52.5 | 9429 | R | |
| 278. | Mookie Betts (9, 29) | 52.4 | 4619 | R | |
| 279. | Waite Hoyt+ (21) | 52.3 | 1423 | 3762.1 | R |
| 280. | Jim O'Rourke+ (23) | 52.2 | 9052 | 19.2 | R |
| 281. | Norm Cash (17) | 52.0 | 7914 | L | |
| Larry Jackson (14) | 52.0 | 1192 | 3262.2 | R | |
| 283. | Lance Berkman (15) | 51.9 | 7814 | B | |
| Dustin Pedroia (14) | 51.9 | 6777 | R | ||
| 285. | Johan Santana (12) | 51.7 | 279 | 2025.2 | L |
| 286. | Luis Gonzalez (19) | 51.6 | 10531 | L | |
| 287. | Earl Averill+ (13) | 51.5 | 7221 | L | |
| Bobby Doerr+ (14) | 51.5 | 8030 | R | ||
| Brian Downing (20) | 51.5 | 9309 | R | ||
| Toby Harrah (17) | 51.5 | 8767 | R | ||
| 291. | Al Orth (15) | 51.3 | 1792 | 3354.2 | L |
| 292. | Carl Mays (15) | 51.2 | 1202 | 3021.1 | L |
| Kirby Puckett+ (12) | 51.2 | 7831 | R | ||
| 294. | Brian Giles (15) | 51.1 | 7836 | L | |
| Willie Wells+ (21) | 51.1 | 4538 | 0.2 | R | |
| 296. | Bob Elliott (15) | 51.0 | 8207 | R | |
| 297. | Tony Phillips (18) | 50.9 | 9110 | B | |
| 298. | Torii Hunter (19) | 50.7 | 9692 | R | |
| 299. | Theodore Breitenstein (11) | 50.6 | 1538 | 2973.1 | L |
| Mark Teixeira (14) | 50.6 | 8029 | B | ||
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 301. | Tommy Bridges (16) | 50.5 | 1144 | 2826.1 | R |
| Jason Giambi (20) | 50.5 | 8908 | L | ||
| Jim Kaat+ (25) | 50.5 | 1363 | 4530.1 | L | |
| Kenny Rogers (20) | 50.5 | 75 | 3302.2 | L | |
| 305. | Joe Kelley+ (17) | 50.4 | 8163 | R | |
| Silver King (10) | 50.4 | 1477 | 3180.2 | R | |
| 307. | Ted Simmons+ (21) | 50.3 | 9685 | B | |
| 308. | Fred Lynn (17) | 50.2 | 7923 | L | |
| 309. | Orlando Cepeda+ (17) | 50.1 | 8699 | R | |
| Mark Langston (16) | 50.1 | 100 | 2962.2 | R | |
| 311. | Roy Oswalt (13) | 50.0 | 796 | 2245.1 | R |
| Wilbur Wood (17) | 50.0 | 381 | 2684.0 | R | |
| 313. | Mickey Cochrane+ (13) | 49.9 | 6211 | L | |
| 314. | Ellis Burks (18) | 49.8 | 8177 | R | |
| Jamie Moyer (25) | 49.8 | 502 | 4074.0 | L | |
| Eddie Rommel (13) | 49.8 | 960 | 2557.0 | R | |
| Turkey Stearnes+ (18) | 49.8 | 4291 | 7.0 | L | |
| Dizzy Trout (15) | 49.8 | 1047 | 2725.2 | R | |
| 319. | Dave Bancroft+ (16) | 49.7 | 8250 | B | |
| Brett Butler (17) | 49.7 | 9545 | L | ||
| Felix Hernandez (15) | 49.7 | 59 | 2729.2 | R | |
| 322. | Bernie Williams (16) | 49.6 | 9053 | B | |
| 323. | Nellie Fox+ (19) | 49.5 | 10351 | L | |
| Jimmy Sheckard (17) | 49.5 | 9147 | L | ||
| 325. | David Wright (14) | 49.2 | 6872 | R | |
| 326. | Jimmy Key (15) | 48.9 | 3 | 2591.2 | R |
| Sandy Koufax+ (12) | 48.9 | 858 | 2324.1 | R | |
| Dutch Leonard (20) | 48.9 | 1161 | 3218.1 | R | |
| 329. | Jim Fregosi (18) | 48.7 | 7404 | R | |
| Dennis Martinez (23) | 48.7 | 604 | 3999.2 | R | |
| 331. | Buddy Myer (17) | 48.6 | 8193 | L | |
| Doc White (13) | 48.6 | 1532 | 3041.0 | L | |
| 333. | Jack Stivetts (11) | 48.5 | 2148 | 2887.2 | R |
| 334. | Heinie Groh (16) | 48.4 | 7040 | R | |
| Manny Machado (11, 29) | 48.4 | 5819 | R | ||
| 336. | Oscar Charleston+ (17) | 48.3 | 3920 | 80.2 | L |
| Larry Gardner (17) | 48.3 | 7714 | L | ||
| 338. | Bob Lemon+ (15) | 48.2 | 1330 | 2850.0 | L |
| 339. | Ralph Kiner+ (10) | 48.1 | 6256 | R | |
| Dolf Luque (20) | 48.1 | 1192 | 3220.1 | R | |
| 341. | Charles Bender+ (16) | 48.0 | 1287 | 3017.0 | R |
| Mickey Lolich (16) | 48.0 | 1017 | 3638.1 | B | |
| Heinie Manush+ (17) | 48.0 | 8422 | L | ||
| Bobby Veach (14) | 48.0 | 7579 | 2.0 | L | |
| 345. | Kiki Cuyler+ (18) | 47.9 | 8100 | R | |
| Buck Ewing+ (18) | 47.9 | 5772 | 47.0 | R | |
| Joe Judge (20) | 47.9 | 9188 | L | ||
| Wally Schang (19) | 47.9 | 6439 | B | ||
| 349. | Ron Guidry (14) | 47.8 | 0 | 2392.0 | L |
| Bobo Newsom (20) | 47.8 | 1442 | 3759.1 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 351. | Johnny Evers+ (18) | 47.7 | 7230 | L | |
| Jim Rice+ (16) | 47.7 | 9058 | R | ||
| 353. | Tony Lazzeri+ (14) | 47.6 | 7314 | R | |
| George Mullin (14) | 47.6 | 1701 | 3686.2 | R | |
| Jimmy Rollins (17) | 47.6 | 10240 | B | ||
| 356. | Satchel Paige+ (21) | 47.5 | 703 | 1729.2 | R |
| 357. | Devon White (17) | 47.3 | 8080 | B | |
| 358. | Curtis Granderson (16) | 47.2 | 8306 | L | |
| Nap Rucker (10) | 47.2 | 859 | 2375.1 | R | |
| 360. | Ryan Braun (14) | 47.1 | 7340 | R | |
| Art Fletcher (13) | 47.1 | 6045 | R | ||
| Bill Foster+ (14) | 47.1 | 644 | 1499.2 | B | |
| Tommy Leach (19) | 47.1 | 9075 | R | ||
| Miguel Tejada (16) | 47.1 | 9205 | R | ||
| 365. | Jesse Tannehill (15) | 47.0 | 1561 | 2759.1 | B |
| Frank Viola (15) | 47.0 | 210 | 2836.1 | L | |
| 367. | Nolan Arenado (10, 31) | 46.9 | 5390 | R | |
| Bob Shawkey (15) | 46.9 | 1136 | 2937.0 | R | |
| 369. | Gene Tenace (15) | 46.8 | 5527 | R | |
| Hippo Vaughn (13) | 46.8 | 1016 | 2730.0 | B | |
| Roy White (15) | 46.8 | 7736 | B | ||
| Hoyt Wilhelm+ (21) | 46.8 | 493 | 2254.1 | R | |
| 373. | Mike Cameron (17) | 46.7 | 7884 | R | |
| 374. | Matt Williams (17) | 46.6 | 7595 | R | |
| 375. | Lave Cross (21) | 46.5 | 9745 | R | |
| Chuck Klein+ (17) | 46.5 | 7172 | L | ||
| Ed Konetchy (15) | 46.5 | 8675 | 16.2 | R | |
| Dale Murphy (18) | 46.5 | 9041 | R | ||
| 379. | Mark Grace (16) | 46.4 | 9290 | 1.0 | L |
| 380. | Bartolo Colon (21) | 46.2 | 326 | 3461.2 | R |
| Dizzy Dean+ (12) | 46.2 | 766 | 1967.1 | R | |
| Vern Stephens (15) | 46.2 | 7243 | R | ||
| Willie Wilson (19) | 46.2 | 8317 | B | ||
| 384. | Murry Dickson (18) | 46.1 | 1143 | 3052.1 | R |
| Thurman Munson (11) | 46.1 | 5905 | R | ||
| 386. | Frank Chance+ (17) | 46.0 | 5138 | R | |
| King Kelly+ (16) | 46.0 | 6457 | 45.2 | R | |
| 388. | Josh Donaldson (12, 36) | 45.9 | 5273 | R | |
| Andrew McCutchen (14, 35) | 45.9 | 7729 | R | ||
| 390. | Rusty Staub (23) | 45.8 | 11229 | L | |
| Adam Wainwright (17, 40) | 45.8 | 846 | 2427.2 | R | |
| Lon Warneke (15) | 45.8 | 1080 | 2782.1 | R | |
| 393. | John McGraw+ (17) | 45.7 | 4946 | L | |
| Del Pratt (13) | 45.7 | 7629 | R | ||
| 395. | Edd Roush+ (18) | 45.6 | 8157 | L | |
| Javier Vazquez (14) | 45.6 | 692 | 2840.0 | R | |
| Omar Vizquel (24) | 45.6 | 12013 | B | ||
| 398. | Herb Pennock+ (22) | 45.5 | 1427 | 3571.2 | B |
| Chris Sale (11, 33) | 45.5 | 27 | 1672.1 | L | |
| Deacon White+ (20) | 45.5 | 6973 | 10.0 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 401. | Larry French (14) | 45.4 | 1198 | 3152.0 | R |
| Augie Galan (16) | 45.4 | 7007 | B | ||
| Addie Joss+ (9) | 45.4 | 919 | 2327.0 | R | |
| 404. | Lou Brock+ (19) | 45.3 | 11240 | L | |
| Tony Fernandez (17) | 45.3 | 8793 | B | ||
| Brad Radke (12) | 45.3 | 34 | 2451.0 | R | |
| 407. | Roger Peckinpaugh (17) | 45.2 | 8396 | R | |
| Giancarlo Stanton (13, 32) | 45.2 | 5738 | R | ||
| 409. | Vida Blue (17) | 45.1 | 618 | 3343.1 | B |
| Larry Doyle (14) | 45.1 | 7401 | L | ||
| Jim Gilliam (17) | 45.1 | 8887 | B | ||
| Claude Passeau (13) | 45.1 | 1051 | 2719.2 | R | |
| 413. | Freddie Freeman (13, 32) | 45.0 | 6858 | L | |
| Harry Stovey (14) | 45.0 | 6848 | 9.1 | R | |
| 415. | Bill Donovan (18) | 44.9 | 1449 | 2964.2 | B |
| J.D. Drew (14) | 44.9 | 6153 | L | ||
| Paul Hines (20) | 44.9 | 7470 | 1.0 | R | |
| Dixie Walker (18) | 44.9 | 7669 | L | ||
| 419. | Rocky Colavito (14) | 44.8 | 7559 | 5.2 | R |
| Bill Freehan (15) | 44.8 | 6900 | R | ||
| Buster Posey (12) | 44.8 | 5607 | R | ||
| 422. | Earle Combs+ (12) | 44.7 | 6514 | L | |
| Red Lucas (16) | 44.7 | 1608 | 2542.0 | L | |
| Steve Rogers (13) | 44.7 | 1045 | 2837.2 | R | |
| 425. | Noodles Hahn (8) | 44.6 | 813 | 2029.1 | L |
| Chuck Knoblauch (12) | 44.6 | 7387 | R | ||
| 427. | Lonny Frey (14) | 44.5 | 6402 | L | |
| Matt Holliday (15) | 44.5 | 7981 | R | ||
| Red Schoendienst+ (19) | 44.5 | 9224 | B | ||
| Troy Tulowitzki (13) | 44.5 | 5415 | R | ||
| Ben Zobrist (14) | 44.5 | 6836 | 1.0 | B | |
| 432. | Cupid Childs (13) | 44.4 | 6770 | L | |
| Carlos Delgado (17) | 44.4 | 8657 | L | ||
| Sam Thompson+ (15) | 44.4 | 6526 | L | ||
| 435. | Nomar Garciaparra (14) | 44.3 | 6116 | R | |
| Brett Gardner (14) | 44.3 | 6614 | L | ||
| Mel Harder (20) | 44.3 | 1315 | 3426.1 | R | |
| 438. | Steve Finley (19) | 44.2 | 10460 | 1.0 | L |
| 439. | George Foster (18) | 44.1 | 7812 | R | |
| 440. | Travis Jackson+ (15) | 44.0 | 6682 | R | |
| 441. | Gil Hodges+ (18) | 43.9 | 8104 | R | |
| Rabbit Maranville+ (23) | 43.9 | 11260 | R | ||
| Carlos Zambrano (12) | 43.9 | 744 | 1959.0 | B | |
| 444. | Al Dark (14) | 43.8 | 7833 | 1.0 | R |
| Charlie Keller (13) | 43.8 | 4604 | L | ||
| Fred Tenney (17) | 43.8 | 8834 | 2.0 | L | |
| 447. | Al Oliver (18) | 43.7 | 9778 | L | |
| Milt Pappas (17) | 43.7 | 1176 | 3186.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Ryan (18) | 43.7 | 9127 | 117.0 | R | |
| Bob Welch (17) | 43.7 | 668 | 3092.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 451. | Julio Franco (23) | 43.6 | 9731 | R | |
| 452. | Adrian Gonzalez (15) | 43.5 | 8046 | L | |
| Jack Morris+ (18) | 43.5 | 1 | 3824.0 | R | |
| 454. | Jon Lester (16) | 43.4 | 423 | 2740.0 | L |
| 455. | Dolph Camilli (12) | 43.3 | 6354 | L | |
| Fielder Jones (15) | 43.3 | 7924 | L | ||
| Curt Simmons (20) | 43.3 | 1257 | 3348.1 | L | |
| 458. | Cliff Lee (13) | 43.2 | 321 | 2156.2 | L |
| 459. | Hugh Duffy+ (17) | 43.1 | 7842 | R | |
| Mel Stottlemyre (11) | 43.1 | 846 | 2661.1 | R | |
| 461. | Ned Garver (14) | 43.0 | 962 | 2477.1 | R |
| Tony Oliva+ (15) | 43.0 | 6880 | L | ||
| Ken Williams (14) | 43.0 | 5625 | L | ||
| 464. | Roger Bresnahan+ (17) | 42.8 | 5389 | 50.1 | R |
| Ben Chapman (15) | 42.8 | 7427 | 141.1 | R | |
| Amos Otis (17) | 42.8 | 8247 | R | ||
| 467. | Jack Chesbro+ (11) | 42.7 | 1155 | 2896.2 | R |
| Jorge Posada (17) | 42.7 | 7150 | B | ||
| 469. | Jose Altuve (12, 32) | 42.6 | 6476 | R | |
| Sad Sam Jones (22) | 42.6 | 1495 | 3883.0 | R | |
| Elmer Smith (14) | 42.6 | 5422 | 1210.1 | L | |
| 472. | Wally Berger (11) | 42.5 | 5666 | R | |
| Schoolboy Rowe (15) | 42.5 | 1023 | 2219.1 | R | |
| 474. | Jose Canseco (17) | 42.4 | 8129 | 1.0 | R |
| Jacob deGrom (8, 34) | 42.4 | 423 | 1261.2 | L | |
| Lenny Dykstra (12) | 42.4 | 5282 | L | ||
| Davey Lopes (16) | 42.4 | 7340 | R | ||
| Don Mattingly (14) | 42.4 | 7722 | L | ||
| 479. | Hughie Jennings+ (18) | 42.3 | 5648 | R | |
| 480. | Felipe Alou (17) | 42.2 | 7908 | R | |
| Harry Brecheen (12) | 42.2 | 746 | 1907.2 | L | |
| Nelson Cruz (18, 41) | 42.2 | 7914 | R | ||
| Phil Rizzuto+ (13) | 42.2 | 6719 | R | ||
| Darryl Strawberry (17) | 42.2 | 6326 | L | ||
| 485. | Harlond Clift (12) | 42.1 | 6895 | R | |
| Gary Gaetti (20) | 42.1 | 9817 | 2.1 | R | |
| Yadier Molina (19, 39) | 42.1 | 8380 | 1.0 | R | |
| 488. | John Candelaria (19) | 41.9 | 688 | 2525.2 | L |
| Curt Flood (15) | 41.9 | 6958 | R | ||
| Placido Polanco (16) | 41.9 | 7887 | R | ||
| 491. | Kid Gleason (22) | 41.8 | 8211 | 2389.1 | B |
| Sam McDowell (15) | 41.8 | 851 | 2492.1 | L | |
| Bill Nicholson (16) | 41.8 | 6420 | L | ||
| Ken Singleton (15) | 41.8 | 8559 | B | ||
| 495. | Dick Bartell (18) | 41.7 | 8745 | R | |
| Doug DeCinces (15) | 41.7 | 6534 | R | ||
| Jason Kendall (15) | 41.7 | 8702 | R | ||
| 498. | Roy Campanella+ (18) | 41.6 | 5656 | 15.1 | R |
| Bryce Harper (11, 29) | 41.6 | 5656 | L | ||
| Jim Perry (17) | 41.6 | 980 | 3285.2 | B | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 501. | Mike Tiernan (13) | 41.5 | 6732 | 19.2 | L |
| Fernando Valenzuela (17) | 41.5 | 1044 | 2930.0 | L | |
| 503. | Jack Fournier (15) | 41.4 | 6034 | 1.0 | L |
| Eddie Stanky (11) | 41.4 | 5439 | R | ||
| 505. | George Van Haltren (17) | 41.3 | 9020 | 689.1 | L |
| Andy Van Slyke (13) | 41.3 | 6495 | L | ||
| 507. | Claude Osteen (18) | 41.2 | 1220 | 3460.2 | L |
| 508. | Tom Candiotti (16) | 41.1 | 360 | 2725.0 | R |
| Frank Dwyer (12) | 41.1 | 1339 | 2819.0 | R | |
| Rich Gossage+ (22) | 41.1 | 93 | 1809.1 | R | |
| 511. | Mark Belanger (18) | 41.0 | 6602 | R | |
| Hardy Richardson (14) | 41.0 | 6044 | 16.0 | R | |
| 513. | Catfish Hunter+ (15) | 40.9 | 710 | 3449.1 | R |
| Camilo Pascual (18) | 40.9 | 1073 | 2930.2 | R | |
| Darrell Porter (17) | 40.9 | 6570 | L | ||
| 516. | Hooks Dauss (15) | 40.8 | 1324 | 3390.2 | R |
| Bob Friend (16) | 40.8 | 1299 | 3611.0 | R | |
| Mike Griffin (12) | 40.8 | 6848 | L | ||
| Sadie McMahon (9) | 40.8 | 1191 | 2634.0 | R | |
| 520. | Roy Thomas (13) | 40.7 | 6602 | 2.2 | L |
| 521. | David Justice (14) | 40.6 | 6602 | L | |
| Gil McDougald (10) | 40.6 | 5398 | R | ||
| 523. | Carney Lansford (15) | 40.5 | 7905 | R | |
| Sam Leever (13) | 40.5 | 1078 | 2660.2 | R | |
| Tim Salmon (14) | 40.5 | 7039 | R | ||
| Cy Seymour (16) | 40.5 | 6227 | 1038.0 | L | |
| Jim Sundberg (16) | 40.5 | 6899 | R | ||
| Virgil Trucks (17) | 40.5 | 1012 | 2682.1 | R | |
| 529. | Pete Browning (13) | 40.4 | 5315 | 0.1 | R |
| 530. | Dave Concepcion (19) | 40.2 | 9641 | 1.1 | R |
| Andy Messersmith (12) | 40.2 | 826 | 2230.1 | R | |
| 532. | Albert Belle (12) | 40.1 | 6676 | R | |
| Dave Parker (19) | 40.1 | 10184 | L | ||
| Smoky Joe Wood (14) | 40.1 | 2282 | 1434.1 | R | |
| Ryan Zimmerman (16) | 40.1 | 7402 | R | ||
| 536. | Al Leiter (19) | 40.0 | 613 | 2391.0 | L |
| Clyde Milan (16) | 40.0 | 8339 | L | ||
| 538. | Moises Alou (17) | 39.9 | 7913 | R | |
| George Gore (14) | 39.9 | 6104 | L | ||
| Tom Zachary (19) | 39.9 | 1236 | 3126.1 | L | |
| 541. | Danny Darwin (21) | 39.8 | 334 | 3016.2 | R |
| Reggie Sanders (17) | 39.8 | 7043 | R | ||
| 543. | Madison Bumgarner (14, 32) | 39.7 | 731 | 2076.1 | R |
| George Burns (15) | 39.7 | 8253 | R | ||
| Pink Hawley (10) | 39.7 | 1307 | 3012.2 | L | |
| 546. | Tommy Henrich (11) | 39.6 | 5411 | L | |
| Lance Parrish (19) | 39.6 | 7797 | R | ||
| Maury Wills (14) | 39.6 | 8306 | B | ||
| 549. | Bill Dinneen (12) | 39.5 | 1281 | 3074.2 | L |
| Rafael Furcal (14) | 39.5 | 7237 | B | ||
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| David Price (14, 36) | 39.5 | 71 | 2111.1 | L | |
| 552. | Jesse Barfield (12) | 39.4 | 5394 | R | |
| George Cuppy (10) | 39.4 | 1066 | 2283.0 | R | |
| Babe Herman (13) | 39.4 | 6230 | L | ||
| Jon Matlack (13) | 39.4 | 541 | 2363.0 | L | |
| 556. | Donie Bush (16) | 39.3 | 8770 | B | |
| Jake Daubert (15) | 39.3 | 8749 | L | ||
| 558. | Curt Davis (13) | 39.2 | 904 | 2325.0 | R |
| Howard Ehmke (15) | 39.2 | 1089 | 2820.2 | R | |
| Jake Peavy (15) | 39.2 | 598 | 2377.0 | R | |
| 561. | Ray Brown+ (14) | 39.1 | 1391 | 1468.1 | B |
| Carl Crawford (15) | 39.1 | 7178 | L | ||
| Rico Petrocelli (13) | 39.1 | 6171 | R | ||
| Boog Powell (17) | 39.1 | 7810 | L | ||
| 565. | Lorenzo Cain (13, 36) | 38.9 | 4716 | R | |
| Jason Heyward (13, 32) | 38.9 | 6194 | L | ||
| Bill Hutchison (9) | 38.9 | 1425 | 3079.1 | R | |
| Russell Martin (14) | 38.9 | 6648 | 4.0 | R | |
| Don Newcombe (12) | 38.9 | 1033 | 2251.2 | L | |
| Paul O'Neill (17) | 38.9 | 8329 | 2.0 | L | |
| 571. | Harold Baines+ (22) | 38.8 | 11092 | L | |
| Charlie Bennett (15) | 38.8 | 4310 | R | ||
| Magglio Ordonez (15) | 38.8 | 7745 | R | ||
| 574. | Lefty Gomez+ (14) | 38.7 | 1024 | 2503.0 | L |
| Juan Gonzalez (17) | 38.7 | 7155 | R | ||
| Ed McKean (13) | 38.7 | 7626 | R | ||
| Hack Wilson+ (12) | 38.7 | 5557 | R | ||
| 578. | Kent Hrbek (14) | 38.6 | 7137 | L | |
| Bill White (13) | 38.6 | 6680 | L | ||
| 580. | Lonnie Smith (17) | 38.5 | 5952 | R | |
| Pie Traynor+ (17) | 38.5 | 8298 | R | ||
| Tim Wallach (17) | 38.5 | 8908 | 2.0 | R | |
| 583. | Johnny Callison (16) | 38.4 | 7437 | L | |
| Josh Gibson+ (14) | 38.4 | 2511 | 1.2 | R | |
| Kirk Gibson (17) | 38.4 | 6656 | L | ||
| Charlie Hough (25) | 38.4 | 250 | 3801.1 | R | |
| Ed Morris (7) | 38.4 | 1157 | 2678.0 | B | |
| 588. | Eric Chavez (17) | 38.3 | 6228 | L | |
| Chili Davis (19) | 38.3 | 9997 | 2.0 | B | |
| Harry Davis (22) | 38.3 | 7390 | R | ||
| Sid Gordon (13) | 38.3 | 5814 | R | ||
| Jeff Pfeffer (13) | 38.3 | 932 | 2407.1 | R | |
| 593. | Ray Lankford (14) | 38.2 | 6675 | L | |
| Bill Madlock (15) | 38.2 | 7372 | R | ||
| Roger Maris (12) | 38.2 | 5847 | L | ||
| 596. | Max Bishop (12) | 38.1 | 5793 | L | |
| Troy Glaus (13) | 38.1 | 6355 | R | ||
| 598. | Steve Garvey (19) | 38.0 | 9466 | R | |
| Hanley Ramirez (15) | 38.0 | 7127 | R | ||
| 600. | Jeff Heath (14) | 37.8 | 5561 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Ernie Lombardi+ (17) | 37.8 | 6353 | R | ||
| Gus Weyhing (14) | 37.8 | 1980 | 4337.0 | R | |
| 603. | Paul Blair (17) | 37.7 | 6673 | R | |
| Terry Turner (17) | 37.7 | 6665 | R | ||
| 605. | Frank Howard (16) | 37.6 | 7353 | R | |
| George Kell+ (15) | 37.6 | 7529 | R | ||
| Dick McAuliffe (16) | 37.6 | 7162 | L | ||
| Anthony Rizzo (12, 32) | 37.6 | 6181 | 1.0 | L | |
| 609. | Lu Blue (13) | 37.5 | 7223 | B | |
| Jim Maloney (12) | 37.5 | 696 | 1849.0 | L | |
| Charlie Root (17) | 37.5 | 1192 | 3197.1 | R | |
| Cy Williams (19) | 37.5 | 7727 | L | ||
| 613. | Mark Gubicza (14) | 37.4 | 0 | 2223.1 | R |
| Jose Reyes (16) | 37.4 | 8240 | 1.0 | B | |
| 615. | Guy Hecker (9) | 37.3 | 3052 | 2924.0 | R |
| John Lackey (15) | 37.3 | 265 | 2840.1 | R | |
| Andrelton Simmons (11, 32) | 37.3 | 4758 | 1.0 | R | |
| 618. | Bullet Joe Bush (17) | 37.2 | 1324 | 3085.1 | R |
| 619. | Jay Bell (18) | 37.1 | 8525 | R | |
| 620. | Dusty Baker (19) | 37.0 | 8022 | R | |
| Phil Cavarretta (22) | 37.0 | 7703 | L | ||
| Fred Dunlap (12) | 37.0 | 4264 | 2.2 | R | |
| Herman Long (16) | 37.0 | 8512 | L | ||
| Kip Selbach (13) | 37.0 | 7122 | R | ||
| 625. | Dick Groat (14) | 36.9 | 8180 | R | |
| Dutch Leonard (11) | 36.9 | 816 | 2192.0 | L | |
| Kyle Seager (11) | 36.9 | 6204 | L | ||
| 628. | Garry Maddox (15) | 36.8 | 6777 | R | |
| Andy Pafko (17) | 36.8 | 7028 | R | ||
| Mule Suttles+ (21) | 36.8 | 3649 | 16.0 | R | |
| Earl Whitehill (17) | 36.8 | 1451 | 3564.2 | L | |
| 632. | Jose Bautista (15) | 36.7 | 7244 | R | |
| Rube Walberg (15) | 36.7 | 1005 | 2644.0 | L | |
| 634. | Jose Ramirez (10, 29) | 36.6 | 4207 | B | |
| George Scott (14) | 36.6 | 8269 | R | ||
| 636. | Bill Mazeroski+ (17) | 36.5 | 8379 | R | |
| Don Money (16) | 36.5 | 6998 | R | ||
| Wally Moses (17) | 36.5 | 8256 | L | ||
| Jose Rijo (14) | 36.5 | 511 | 1880.0 | R | |
| 640. | Bill Bradley (14) | 36.4 | 6052 | 1.0 | R |
| 641. | Ray Caldwell (12) | 36.3 | 1270 | 2242.0 | L |
| Rick Wise (18) | 36.3 | 741 | 3127.1 | R | |
| 643. | Candy Cummings+ (6) | 36.2 | 1084 | 2149.2 | R |
| 644. | Don Buford (10) | 36.1 | 5347 | B | |
| Eric Davis (17) | 36.1 | 6147 | R | ||
| Art Devlin (10) | 36.1 | 5250 | R | ||
| 647. | Cecil Cooper (17) | 36.0 | 7939 | L | |
| Paul Derringer (15) | 36.0 | 1357 | 3645.0 | R | |
| Bob Rush (13) | 36.0 | 872 | 2410.2 | R | |
| 650. | Fritz Ostermueller (15) | 35.9 | 823 | 2066.2 | L |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Freddy Parent (12) | 35.9 | 5592 | R | ||
| 652. | Jim Bottomley+ (16) | 35.8 | 8358 | L | |
| Freddie Fitzsimmons (19) | 35.8 | 1264 | 3223.2 | R | |
| Wally Joyner (16) | 35.8 | 8115 | L | ||
| Starling Marte (11, 33) | 35.8 | 4934 | R | ||
| 656. | Josh Beckett (14) | 35.7 | 335 | 2051.0 | R |
| Danny Murphy (16) | 35.7 | 5996 | R | ||
| Ed Williamson (13) | 35.7 | 5082 | 35.0 | R | |
| 659. | Burt Hooton (15) | 35.6 | 913 | 2652.0 | R |
| Deacon Phillippe (13) | 35.6 | 1070 | 2607.0 | R | |
| Ed Reulbach (13) | 35.6 | 985 | 2632.1 | R | |
| Mickey Vernon (20) | 35.6 | 9839 | L | ||
| 663. | Edwin Encarnacion (16) | 35.5 | 8126 | R | |
| Tommy Holmes (11) | 35.5 | 5566 | L | ||
| Willie Kamm (13) | 35.5 | 6946 | R | ||
| Denny Lyons (13) | 35.5 | 5029 | R | ||
| 667. | Dave Foutz (13) | 35.4 | 4859 | 1997.1 | R |
| Miller Huggins+ (13) | 35.4 | 6825 | B | ||
| Rick Rhoden (16) | 35.4 | 830 | 2593.2 | R | |
| 670. | Cool Papa Bell+ (21) | 35.3 | 5405 | 309.2 | B |
| 671. | Jack Taylor (10) | 35.2 | 1165 | 2626.0 | R |
| 672. | George Burns (16) | 35.1 | 7247 | R | |
| Ron Fairly (21) | 35.1 | 8437 | L | ||
| Bump Hadley (16) | 35.1 | 1147 | 2945.2 | R | |
| Dan Haren (13) | 35.1 | 478 | 2419.2 | R | |
| Jerry Reuss (22) | 35.1 | 1195 | 3669.2 | L | |
| 677. | Doyle Alexander (19) | 35.0 | 300 | 3367.2 | R |
| Brady Anderson (15) | 35.0 | 7737 | L | ||
| Carlos Correa (8, 27) | 35.0 | 3361 | R | ||
| Tom Gordon (21) | 35.0 | 2 | 2108.0 | R | |
| Howie Kendrick (15) | 35.0 | 6421 | R | ||
| Brickyard Kennedy (12) | 35.0 | 1342 | 3030.0 | R | |
| Eddie Yost (18) | 35.0 | 9177 | R | ||
| 684. | William Bell (14) | 34.9 | 749 | 1438.2 | R |
| Will White (10) | 34.9 | 1537 | 3542.2 | B | |
| 686. | Jimmy Dykes (22) | 34.8 | 9353 | 2.0 | R |
| Frank White (18) | 34.8 | 8468 | R | ||
| 688. | Shawn Green (15) | 34.7 | 7963 | L | |
| Claude Ritchey (13) | 34.7 | 6858 | B | ||
| Bobby Shantz (16) | 34.7 | 646 | 1935.2 | R | |
| 691. | Shin-Soo Choo (16) | 34.6 | 7157 | L | |
| Carl Furillo (15) | 34.6 | 7022 | R | ||
| Derrek Lee (15) | 34.6 | 7963 | R | ||
| Stuffy McInnis (19) | 34.6 | 8642 | R | ||
| Jered Weaver (12) | 34.6 | 57 | 2067.1 | R | |
| 696. | Jeff Cirillo (14) | 34.5 | 6136 | 1.0 | R |
| Ken Griffey (19) | 34.5 | 8049 | L | ||
| Pedro Guerrero (15) | 34.5 | 6115 | R | ||
| 699. | Travis Fryman (13) | 34.4 | 7217 | R | |
| Alex Gordon (14) | 34.4 | 7250 | 2.1 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Frank Killen (10) | 34.4 | 1148 | 2511.1 | L | |
| B.J. Surhoff (19) | 34.4 | 9106 | L | ||
| Tim Wakefield (19) | 34.4 | 130 | 3226.1 | R | |
| Jud Wilson+ (21) | 34.4 | 3556 | L | ||
| 705. | Thornton Lee (16) | 34.3 | 886 | 2331.1 | L |
| Derek Lowe (17) | 34.3 | 534 | 2671.1 | R | |
| Johnny Pesky (10) | 34.3 | 5516 | L | ||
| Howie Pollet (14) | 34.3 | 790 | 2107.1 | L | |
| Christian Yelich (10, 30) | 34.3 | 4954 | L | ||
| 710. | Bob Allison (13) | 34.2 | 5924 | R | |
| Chris Carpenter (15) | 34.2 | 501 | 2219.1 | R | |
| Freddy Garcia (15) | 34.2 | 99 | 2264.0 | R | |
| Harry Howell (13) | 34.2 | 1519 | 2567.2 | R | |
| Willie McGee (18) | 34.2 | 8188 | B | ||
| John Tudor (12) | 34.2 | 443 | 1797.0 | L | |
| 716. | Ron Gant (16) | 34.1 | 7320 | R | |
| Bruce Hurst (15) | 34.1 | 331 | 2417.1 | L | |
| Marty McManus (15) | 34.1 | 7568 | R | ||
| 719. | Johnny Cueto (15, 36) | 34.0 | 655 | 2046.1 | R |
| Corey Kluber (12, 36) | 34.0 | 32 | 1461.1 | R | |
| Dan McGann (12) | 34.0 | 6057 | B | ||
| Ken McMullen (16) | 34.0 | 5731 | R | ||
| Slim Sallee (14) | 34.0 | 1032 | 2821.2 | R | |
| 724. | Tony Cuccinello (15) | 33.9 | 6880 | R | |
| Russ Ford (7) | 33.9 | 571 | 1487.1 | R | |
| Rick Sutcliffe (18) | 33.9 | 657 | 2697.2 | L | |
| 727. | Michael Brantley (14, 35) | 33.8 | 5984 | L | |
| Ray Durham (14) | 33.8 | 8423 | B | ||
| Billy Nash (15) | 33.8 | 6742 | 1.1 | R | |
| Robby Thompson (11) | 33.8 | 5235 | R | ||
| Bobby Thomson (15) | 33.8 | 6961 | R | ||
| 732. | Dom DiMaggio (11) | 33.6 | 6478 | R | |
| Nick Markakis (15) | 33.6 | 9321 | L | ||
| Heinie Zimmerman (13) | 33.6 | 5744 | R | ||
| 735. | Joe Adcock (17) | 33.5 | 7305 | R | |
| Mark Ellis (12) | 33.5 | 5728 | R | ||
| 737. | Smoky Burgess (18) | 33.4 | 5014 | L | |
| Ken Caminiti (15) | 33.4 | 7127 | B | ||
| George Grantham (13) | 33.4 | 5900 | L | ||
| Anthony Rendon (10, 32) | 33.4 | 4581 | R | ||
| 741. | Kid Elberfeld (14) | 33.3 | 5296 | R | |
| Elbie Fletcher (12) | 33.3 | 5828 | L | ||
| Harvey Haddix (14) | 33.3 | 871 | 2235.0 | L | |
| Ken Keltner (13) | 33.3 | 6316 | R | ||
| Charlie Leibrandt (14) | 33.3 | 315 | 2308.0 | R | |
| Dwayne Murphy (12) | 33.3 | 5242 | L | ||
| Gene Woodling (17) | 33.3 | 6618 | L | ||
| 748. | Ray Schalk+ (18) | 33.2 | 6244 | R | |
| 749. | Rick Monday (19) | 33.1 | 7162 | L | |
| Earl Torgeson (15) | 33.1 | 6046 | L | ||
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 751. | Gavvy Cravath (11) | 33.0 | 4663 | R | |
| Johnny Logan (13) | 33.0 | 5893 | R | ||
| 753. | Jim Devlin (5) | 32.9 | 1202 | 1405.0 | R |
| Richie Hebner (18) | 32.9 | 7027 | L | ||
| Brian Jordan (15) | 32.9 | 5646 | R | ||
| Van Mungo (14) | 32.9 | 838 | 2113.0 | R | |
| 757. | Bill Doran (12) | 32.8 | 5922 | B | |
| Ron Hunt (12) | 32.8 | 6158 | R | ||
| 759. | Rico Carty (15) | 32.7 | 6318 | R | |
| Mort Cooper (11) | 32.7 | 724 | 1840.2 | R | |
| Sid Fernandez (15) | 32.7 | 629 | 1866.2 | L | |
| Mickey Rivers (15) | 32.7 | 6027 | L | ||
| Justin Upton (15, 34) | 32.7 | 7592 | R | ||
| Ross Youngs+ (10) | 32.7 | 5337 | L | ||
| 765. | Jesse Haines+ (19) | 32.6 | 1215 | 3208.2 | R |
| Pat Hentgen (14) | 32.6 | 97 | 2075.1 | R | |
| Adam Jones (14) | 32.6 | 7516 | R | ||
| Riggs Stephenson (14) | 32.6 | 5136 | R | ||
| Sam West (16) | 32.6 | 6974 | L | ||
| Jimmy Williams (11) | 32.6 | 6138 | R | ||
| 771. | Roy Cullenbine (10) | 32.5 | 4787 | B | |
| Billy Hoy (14) | 32.5 | 8386 | L | ||
| Francisco Lindor (8, 28) | 32.5 | 4239 | B | ||
| Joe Start (16) | 32.5 | 4907 | L | ||
| Stephen Strasburg (12, 33) | 32.5 | 521 | 1465.1 | R | |
| John Valentin (11) | 32.5 | 4511 | R | ||
| 777. | Rube Marquard+ (18) | 32.4 | 1196 | 3306.2 | B |
| Aramis Ramirez (18) | 32.4 | 8986 | R | ||
| Edgar Renteria (16) | 32.4 | 9066 | R | ||
| Al Rosen (10) | 32.4 | 4374 | R | ||
| Ezra Sutton (18) | 32.4 | 5537 | 6.0 | R | |
| Kevin Youkilis (10) | 32.4 | 4436 | R | ||
| 783. | Darin Erstad (14) | 32.3 | 6628 | L | |
| Vern Law (16) | 32.3 | 1003 | 2672.0 | R | |
| 785. | Gerrit Cole (10, 31) | 32.2 | 286 | 1501.0 | R |
| John Denny (13) | 32.2 | 656 | 2148.2 | R | |
| Eddie Lopat (12) | 32.2 | 999 | 2439.1 | L | |
| Justin Turner (14, 37) | 32.2 | 4784 | 1.0 | R | |
| 789. | Monte Irvin+ (18) | 32.1 | 4026 | R | |
| Sonny Siebert (12) | 32.1 | 725 | 2152.0 | R | |
| 791. | Scott Fletcher (15) | 32.0 | 5976 | R | |
| Victor Martinez (16) | 32.0 | 8166 | B | ||
| Brian McCann (15) | 32.0 | 6850 | L | ||
| Bobby Murcer (17) | 32.0 | 7718 | L | ||
| 795. | Johnny Antonelli (12) | 31.9 | 745 | 1992.1 | L |
| Larry Dierker (14) | 31.9 | 876 | 2333.2 | R | |
| Marty Marion (13) | 31.9 | 6143 | R | ||
| Frank McCormick (13) | 31.9 | 6207 | R | ||
| George Springer (9, 32) | 31.9 | 4083 | R | ||
| Barry Zito (15) | 31.9 | 418 | 2576.2 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| 801. | Kevin Kiermaier (10, 32) | 31.8 | 3250 | L | |
| 802. | Charlie Ferguson (4) | 31.7 | 1078 | 1514.2 | B |
| Andres Galarraga (19) | 31.7 | 8916 | R | ||
| Wally Pipp (15) | 31.7 | 7837 | L | ||
| Rudy York (13) | 31.7 | 6723 | R | ||
| 806. | Ed Brandt (11) | 31.6 | 878 | 2268.1 | L |
| Carlos Santana (13, 36) | 31.6 | 7187 | B | ||
| Chick Stahl (10) | 31.6 | 5718 | 2.0 | L | |
| Jose Valentin (16) | 31.6 | 6317 | B | ||
| 810. | Andy Benes (14) | 31.5 | 880 | 2505.1 | R |
| Claude Hendrix (10) | 31.5 | 991 | 2371.1 | R | |
| Eddie Joost (17) | 31.5 | 6791 | R | ||
| Shane Victorino (12) | 31.5 | 5164 | R | ||
| 814. | Ted Kluszewski (15) | 31.4 | 6470 | L | |
| Bill Lee (14) | 31.4 | 1099 | 2864.0 | R | |
| Bill Russell (18) | 31.4 | 8021 | R | ||
| 817. | Mike Boddicker (14) | 31.3 | 0 | 2123.2 | R |
| 818. | Jacoby Ellsbury (11) | 31.2 | 5375 | L | |
| Chick Hafey+ (13) | 31.2 | 5116 | R | ||
| Topsy Hartsel (14) | 31.2 | 5842 | L | ||
| Adonis Terry (14) | 31.2 | 2555 | 3514.1 | R | |
| 822. | Duke Farrell (18) | 31.1 | 6269 | B | |
| Bill Sherdel (15) | 31.1 | 1071 | 2709.1 | L | |
| Brandon Webb (7) | 31.1 | 457 | 1319.2 | R | |
| 825. | Bill Joyce (8) | 31.0 | 4163 | L | |
| Ken Raffensberger (15) | 31.0 | 779 | 2151.2 | R | |
| 827. | Elvis Andrus (14, 33) | 30.9 | 7770 | R | |
| Jim Bagby (9) | 30.9 | 728 | 1821.2 | B | |
| Orlando Hudson (11) | 30.9 | 5413 | B | ||
| Hunter Pence (14) | 30.9 | 7006 | R | ||
| Greg Vaughn (15) | 30.9 | 7070 | R | ||
| 832. | Rick Ferrell+ (18) | 30.8 | 7076 | R | |
| 833. | Jim Barr (12) | 30.7 | 601 | 2065.1 | R |
| Bill Byrd (15) | 30.7 | 870 | 1344.2 | B | |
| Ice Box Chamberlain (10) | 30.7 | 1146 | 2521.2 | R | |
| James Shields (13) | 30.7 | 154 | 2616.0 | R | |
| 837. | Willis Hudlin (16) | 30.6 | 1006 | 2613.1 | R |
| Firpo Marberry (14) | 30.6 | 731 | 2067.1 | R | |
| Chris Speier (19) | 30.6 | 8155 | R | ||
| 840. | Ginger Beaumont (12) | 30.5 | 6313 | L | |
| Xander Bogaerts (10, 29) | 30.5 | 4943 | R | ||
| Arlie Latham (17) | 30.5 | 7524 | R | ||
| Sal Maglie (10) | 30.5 | 645 | 1723.0 | R | |
| Greg Swindell (17) | 30.5 | 286 | 2233.1 | R | |
| Hank Thompson (12) | 30.5 | 4217 | L | ||
| 846. | Mike Garcia (14) | 30.4 | 792 | 2174.2 | R |
| Mike Hargrove (12) | 30.4 | 6694 | L | ||
| John Hiller (15) | 30.4 | 108 | 1242.0 | R | |
| Frank Lary (12) | 30.4 | 830 | 2162.1 | R | |
| Gary Matthews (16) | 30.4 | 8189 | R | ||
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Joe Nuxhall (16) | 30.4 | 861 | 2302.2 | L | |
| Jhonny Peralta (15) | 30.4 | 7319 | R | ||
| Harry Steinfeldt (14) | 30.4 | 6712 | R | ||
| 854. | Brandon Crawford (12, 35) | 30.3 | 5626 | L | |
| Teddy Higuera (9) | 30.3 | 0 | 1380.0 | B | |
| Cecil Travis (12) | 30.3 | 5417 | L | ||
| 857. | Bobby Bonilla (16) | 30.2 | 8257 | 1.0 | B |
| Lance Johnson (14) | 30.2 | 5800 | L | ||
| Joe Kuhel (18) | 30.2 | 9097 | L | ||
| Max Lanier (14) | 30.2 | 599 | 1619.1 | R | |
| Woody Williams (15) | 30.2 | 617 | 2216.1 | R | |
| Hooks Wiltse (12) | 30.2 | 834 | 2112.1 | R | |
| 863. | Del Ennis (14) | 30.1 | 7944 | R | |
| Sherm Lollar (18) | 30.1 | 6220 | R | ||
| Kevin McReynolds (12) | 30.1 | 6039 | R | ||
| Salvador Perez (11, 32) | 30.1 | 4700 | R | ||
| 867. | Liván Hernández (17) | 30.0 | 1113 | 3189.0 | R |
| John Titus (11) | 30.0 | 5843 | L | ||
| Hal Trosky (11) | 30.0 | 5750 | L | ||
| 870. | Dean Chance (11) | 29.9 | 759 | 2147.1 | R |
| Bob Ewing (11) | 29.9 | 955 | 2301.0 | R | |
| Von Hayes (12) | 29.9 | 6052 | L | ||
| 873. | Kevin Millwood (16) | 29.8 | 550 | 2720.1 | R |
| Johnny Podres (15) | 29.8 | 852 | 2265.0 | L | |
| Pete Runnels (14) | 29.8 | 7329 | L | ||
| 876. | Phil Garner (16) | 29.7 | 6861 | R | |
| Javy Lopez (15) | 29.7 | 5793 | R | ||
| Lance Lynn (10, 35) | 29.7 | 333 | 1583.2 | B | |
| Joe Niekro (22) | 29.7 | 1165 | 3584.1 | R | |
| Preacher Roe (12) | 29.7 | 722 | 1914.1 | R | |
| 881. | Asdrubal Cabrera (15) | 29.6 | 7401 | 1.1 | B |
| Marquis Grissom (17) | 29.6 | 8959 | R | ||
| Dick McBride (6) | 29.6 | 1209 | 2082.0 | ||
| Hal Schumacher (13) | 29.6 | 961 | 2482.1 | R | |
| Lloyd Waner+ (18) | 29.6 | 8337 | L | ||
| 886. | Bing Miller (16) | 29.5 | 6895 | R | |
| Raul Mondesí (13) | 29.5 | 6369 | R | ||
| Brian Roberts (14) | 29.5 | 6253 | B | ||
| Jason Schmidt (14) | 29.5 | 712 | 1996.1 | R | |
| 890. | Johnny Sain (11) | 29.4 | 857 | 2125.2 | R |
| Charles Zimmer (19) | 29.4 | 5078 | R | ||
| 892. | Ray Chapman (9) | 29.3 | 4608 | R | |
| Tom Haller (12) | 29.3 | 4520 | L | ||
| Jim Piersall (17) | 29.3 | 6593 | R | ||
| Mickey Tettleton (14) | 29.3 | 5745 | B | ||
| 896. | Doug Drabek (13) | 29.2 | 808 | 2535.0 | R |
| Kevin Tapani (13) | 29.2 | 311 | 2265.0 | R | |
| Jayson Werth (15) | 29.2 | 6366 | R | ||
| 899. | Matt Cain (13) | 29.1 | 708 | 2085.2 | R |
| Luis Castillo (15) | 29.1 | 7471 | B | ||
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| George Hendrick (18) | 29.1 | 7834 | R | ||
| Johnny Kling (13) | 29.1 | 4655 | R | ||
| Buddy Lewis (11) | 29.1 | 5940 | L | ||
| Kevin Mitchell (13) | 29.1 | 4696 | R | ||
| Red Rolfe (10) | 29.1 | 5407 | L | ||
| Dutch Ruether (11) | 29.1 | 1074 | 2124.2 | L | |
| Nip Winters (8) | 29.1 | 706 | 1114.2 | L | |
| 908. | Benny Kauff (8) | 29.0 | 3566 | L | |
| Tino Martinez (16) | 29.0 | 8044 | L | ||
| Marcus Semien (10, 31) | 29.0 | 4526 | R | ||
| 911. | Coco Crisp (15) | 28.9 | 6627 | B | |
| Baby Doll Jacobson (11) | 28.9 | 6078 | R | ||
| Ellis Kinder (12) | 28.9 | 499 | 1479.2 | R | |
| Kevin Seitzer (12) | 28.9 | 6062 | 0.1 | R | |
| Lee Smith+ (18) | 28.9 | 71 | 1289.1 | R | |
| 916. | John Anderson (14) | 28.8 | 6785 | B | |
| A.J. Burnett (17) | 28.8 | 575 | 2731.1 | R | |
| Mike Donlin (12) | 28.8 | 4294 | 16.1 | L | |
| Billy Jurges (17) | 28.8 | 7018 | R | ||
| Art Nehf (15) | 28.8 | 1047 | 2707.2 | L | |
| Elmer Valo (20) | 28.8 | 6092 | L | ||
| 922. | Edgardo Alfonzo (12) | 28.7 | 6108 | R | |
| Bob Bailey (17) | 28.7 | 7043 | R | ||
| Henry Larkin (10) | 28.7 | 5303 | R | ||
| Gary Peters (14) | 28.7 | 875 | 2081.0 | L | |
| Chris Short (15) | 28.7 | 786 | 2325.0 | R | |
| 927. | Lew Burdette (18) | 28.6 | 1124 | 3067.1 | R |
| Aaron Judge (7, 30) | 28.6 | 2651 | R | ||
| Alfonso Soriano (16) | 28.6 | 8395 | R | ||
| Vernon Wells (15) | 28.6 | 7212 | R | ||
| 931. | Don Baylor (19) | 28.5 | 9401 | R | |
| Ossie Bluege (18) | 28.5 | 7458 | R | ||
| Kris Bryant (8, 30) | 28.5 | 3911 | R | ||
| Alex Fernandez (10) | 28.5 | 146 | 1760.1 | R | |
| 935. | José Abreu (9, 35) | 28.4 | 5007 | R | |
| Bobby Avila (11) | 28.4 | 5344 | R | ||
| Buck Leonard+ (14) | 28.4 | 2556 | L | ||
| J.D. Martinez (12, 34) | 28.4 | 5453 | R | ||
| Terry Pendleton (15) | 28.4 | 7637 | B | ||
| Brandon Phillips (17) | 28.4 | 7992 | R | ||
| Jack Rowe (12) | 28.4 | 4626 | L | ||
| 942. | Gio Gonzalez (13) | 28.3 | 475 | 1933.0 | R |
| Carlos Lee (14) | 28.3 | 8787 | R | ||
| Freddie Lindstrom+ (13) | 28.3 | 6109 | R | ||
| Tim McCarver (21) | 28.3 | 6206 | L | ||
| Lee Meadows (15) | 28.3 | 1201 | 3160.2 | L | |
| Terry Puhl (15) | 28.3 | 5480 | L | ||
| Cesar Tovar (12) | 28.3 | 6177 | 1.0 | R | |
| 949. | Josh Hamilton (9) | 28.2 | 4350 | L | |
| Mike Hampton (16) | 28.2 | 845 | 2268.1 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | PA | IP | Bats/Throws |
| Sixto Lezcano (12) | 28.2 | 4814 | R | ||
| Lindy McDaniel (21) | 28.2 | 412 | 2139.1 | R | |
| Bob Meusel (11) | 28.2 | 6031 | R | ||
| Melvin Mora (13) | 28.2 | 6158 | R | ||
| Jarrod Washburn (12) | 28.2 | 53 | 1863.2 | L | |
| Bob Watson (19) | 28.2 | 6962 | R | ||
| Rondell White (15) | 28.2 | 5852 | R | ||
| 958. | Del Crandall (16) | 28.1 | 5584 | R | |
| J.J. Hardy (13) | 28.1 | 6309 | R | ||
| Paul Konerko (18) | 28.1 | 9505 | R | ||
| Denis Menke (13) | 28.1 | 5936 | R | ||
| 962. | Trevor Hoffman+ (18) | 28.0 | 36 | 1089.1 | R |
| Terry Steinbach (14) | 28.0 | 5905 | R | ||
| Amos Strunk (17) | 28.0 | 5828 | L | ||
| 965. | General Crowder (11) | 27.9 | 929 | 2344.1 | L |
| Jackie Jensen (11) | 27.9 | 6080 | R | ||
| Hal McRae (19) | 27.9 | 8059 | R | ||
| Mike Moore (14) | 27.9 | 1 | 2831.2 | R | |
| Roy Smalley (13) | 27.9 | 6596 | B | ||
| Denard Span (11) | 27.9 | 5956 | L | ||
| Trevor Story (7, 29) | 27.9 | 3309 | R | ||
| 972. | DJ LeMahieu (12, 33) | 27.8 | 5510 | R | |
| Jack McDowell (12) | 27.8 | 0 | 1889.0 | R | |
| Jouett Meekin (10) | 27.8 | 1172 | 2605.1 | R | |
| George Mogridge (15) | 27.8 | 843 | 2265.2 | L | |
| Reb Russell (9) | 27.8 | 1063 | 1291.2 | L | |
| Grady Sizemore (10) | 27.8 | 4724 | L | ||
| Garry Templeton (16) | 27.8 | 8208 | B | ||
| 979. | Ross Barnes (9) | 27.7 | 2507 | 1.1 | R |
| Carlos Guillen (14) | 27.7 | 5277 | B | ||
| Mel Parnell (10) | 27.7 | 729 | 1752.2 | L | |
| Martin Prado (14) | 27.7 | 5861 | R | ||
| Scott Sanderson (19) | 27.7 | 571 | 2561.2 | R | |
| Billy Wagner (16) | 27.7 | 21 | 903.0 | L | |
| Don Wilson (9) | 27.7 | 664 | 1748.1 | R | |
| 986. | Clete Boyer (16) | 27.6 | 6368 | R | |
| Kevin Gross (15) | 27.6 | 759 | 2487.2 | R | |
| Dave Henderson (14) | 27.6 | 5677 | R | ||
| Lloyd Moseby (12) | 27.6 | 6574 | L | ||
| Earl Wilson (11) | 27.6 | 838 | 2051.2 | R | |
| Kerry Wood (14) | 27.6 | 404 | 1380.0 | R | |
| 992. | Chris Chambliss (17) | 27.5 | 8314 | L | |
| Syl Johnson (19) | 27.5 | 757 | 2165.2 | R | |
| Manny Sanguillen (13) | 27.5 | 5383 | R | ||
| Jean Segura (11, 32) | 27.5 | 5384 | R | ||
| Randy Winn (13) | 27.5 | 6878 | B | ||
| 997. | Brandon Belt (12, 34) | 27.4 | 4901 | L | |
| Bob Boone (19) | 27.4 | 8148 | R | ||
| Buck Herzog (13) | 27.4 | 6057 | R | ||
| George Zettlein (6) | 27.4 | 1109 | 2176.2 | R |
